This article has been chosen as a Making Sense of These Times
FIVE STAR PIECE
An anti war paean. "We must also agree not to give in to the urge to value the lives of innocent Americans over the lives of innocent people in other countries...I am on the side of the people no matter where they live who will suffer the violence, not the leaders...I am on the side of peace, not war. I am on the side of justice, not vengeance." Jensen's stirring call was so widely circulated that Bill O'Reilly had him on his show. I saw it. Jensen was heroically polite as Drain-the-Swamp O'Reilly didn't let him finish a sentence.
-Suzanne-
September 21, 2001
Why I Will Not Rally Around The President
Robert Jensen
We are told that in this time of crisis, all good Americans should rally
around the president and the flag. I will rally, but not around a leader
calling for war or a symbol of nationalism.
It is easy to understand the
emotion behind the chanting of "USA, USA." But I will not chant. In this
time of crisis, I will rally around policies that seek peace and security,
for all people everywhere. And instead of chanting, I will speak quietly
about the grief we all feel, and loudly about the need to resist our
leaders' plans for global war.
Decent people agree that in this time of
crisis, we cannot let the lines of color and culture, of language and
religion, divide us. But we need to go another step, to understand that the
lines dividing people based on nations are just as dangerous. We must also
agree not to give in to the urge to value the lives of innocent Americans
over the lives of innocent people in other countries.
For the past few
days in person and on the phone, through email and on the radio I have
been called "unpatriotic," condemned as a "traitor" and labeled
"anti-American" because my writing has opposed the drive to war, the call
for blood to avenge those who died in the terror attacks. But I also have
heard from many others who also are concerned that U.S. officials will take
us into a war that will bring only more death, pain and grief, leaving us
less secure. They want to speak out but fear being attacked for not being
"good Americans." This is a moment when we need the courage to say that
being a good American does not mean supporting a war so violent and so
indiscriminate that more innocent people will die.
That does not mean we
renounce the ideals of freedom and justice so often associated with the
United States; we should hold onto those ideals more fiercely than ever and
put them into practice by resisting the rush to war. We should honor the
ideals of this country by saying, in as clear a voice as we can manage: Not
in our name will the United States seek vengeance or go forward to kill.
It is important to read closely the joint resolution passed by Congress,
which authorizes the president "to use all necessary and appropriate force
against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned,
authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on Sept.
11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons, in order to prevent any
future acts of international terrorism against the United States by such
nations, organizations or persons." That is not a resolution based on a
quest for justice. It is an open-ended invitation to attack anyone U.S.
leaders decide to target.
And those leaders Dick Cheney and Colin Powell
among them are some of the same people who during the Gulf War unleashed
attacks not only on military targets but on civilians and the entire
civilian infrastructure of Iraq, killing hundreds of thousands of innocent
people during and after the war. This resolution, and the statements from
the Bush administration about an ongoing global war, suggest that what is
coming will be even more frightening.
When we speak out against war in
public, we will find support, but we also should expect hostility. We should
expect the question posed by one of the people who wrote to condemn me:
"Whose side are you on?" The answers to that are simple: I am on the
side of the people no matter where they live who will suffer the
violence, not the leaders no matter where they live who will plan it.
I am on the side of peace, not war. I am on the side of justice, not
vengeance. And most important, I am on the side of hope, not despair. We
do not have the luxury of despair right now. There is too much at stake for
too many people.
Robert Jensen is a professor of journalism at the University of Texas
His Website: http://uts.cc.utexas.edu/~rjensen/home.htm
Email: (rjensen@uts.cc.utexas.edu)
Use your browser's BACK button to return to your previous page.
Visit our other FIVE STAR PIECES.